Intellectual Property Roundup

Ruling: Amazon Can’t Own ‘.Amazon’ (The Wall Street Journal)
ICANN’s Governmental Advisory Committee recommended against Amazon taking control of the ‘.Amazon’ domain, perhaps in part because of objections from Latin American countries served by the Amazon River.

Why Startups Are Sporting Increasingly Quirky Names (The Wall Street Journal)
With about 252 million domain names currently registered across the Internet, short, recognizable dot-com Web addresses have long been taken, prompting startup companies to come up with misspelled, made-up, and mashed-up names.

Google, Amazon.com Win Appeal to Toss Internet Patents (Bloomberg)
Google and Amazon won a U.S. appeals court ruling in a case of a former university researcher who claimed his patents covered some of the Internet’s most basic interactive functions.

Charts: How Spotify is Killing Music Piracy (paidContent)
Online music service Spotify published a report that shows that piracy in the Netherlands has gone down just as Spotify has become more popular in the country.

Is Flipboard a Partner or a Competitor For Publishers and Content Creators? Yes (paidContent)
With the launch of a web version, Flipboard highlights how far it has evolved from its early days as a standalone app, and how it is both a partner and a potential competitor for content companies.


Keith Kupferschmid is General Counsel and SVP, Intellectual Property Policy & Enforcement at SIIA.

Intellectual Property Roundup

White House, Tech Giants Aim to Keep Online Ads Off Rogue Sites (CNET) The White House and eight major tech companies unveiled best practices for online ad networks aimed at cutting off revenue to websites selling counterfeit goods or engaging in copyright piracy. Read the White House release here.

Has Patent, Will Sue – An Alert to Corporate America (The New York Times) Inside the mind of a patent troll – IPNav, owned by Erich Spangenberg, is a Dallas-based company that helps “turn idle patents into cash cows,” with its typical client an inventor or corporation demanding a license fee from an infringer.

Goodreads Hit With Copyright Suit Over Fan Photo (paidContent) Photo agency BWP Media has filed a copyright lawsuit against Amazon’s Goodreads site over a celebrity image posted by one of the site’s members.

Executives are Biggest Risk for Copyright Infringement (Fort Mill Times) A recent study found that nearly half the executives surveyed for the study are potentially exposing their organizations to the risk of copyright infringement violations.

RIAA Wants Infamous File-Sharer to Campaign Against Piracy (Wired) The RIAA offered music file-sharer Jammie Thomas-Rasset a reduction of her $222,000 fine if she agreed to make a public statement against piracy.

Broadcasters Lose Final Appeal to Take Down Aereo (Ars Technica)
A coalition of broadcasters, in its suit against Aereo, asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit to take their case “en banc,” but the court declined.


Keith Kupferschmid is General Counsel and SVP, Intellectual Property Policy & Enforcement at SIIA.

SIIA Supports PATENT Jobs Act, Says USPTO Should be Exempt from Sequestration

The USPTO should be exempt from about $150 million in budget cuts from sequestration, because it pays for itself with its own user fees, and does not contribute to the budget deficit. SIIA supports a new bill to that end, called H.R. 2582, “Patents and Trademarks Encourage New Technology (PATENT) Jobs Act,” which was introduced by Rep Honda (D-CA), and co-sponsored by two fellow Californians — Reps. Lofgren and Eshoo (D-Calif.) on June 28.

Much of the debate over PTO funding hinges on whether patent payments are “voluntary” under the Budget Control Act, which was triggered this past March. The act exempts voluntary fees paid to the government from sequestration, and it would seem that the PTO would fall under this exemption. However, it was decided that user fees paid to the PTO are not “voluntary” because only the federal government can issue them.  This line of reasoning is at odds with past treatment of PTO funds by Congress and the Administration.

When Congress passed and the President signed the America Invents Act (AIA) 21 months ago, it was explicitly recognized that fees collected by the USPTO are different from regular discretionary government spending.  The act ensured that excess fees collected by the USPTO are used to fund programs to improve patent quality and pendency, and to ensure the continued provision of critical, time-sensitive services.

The budget cuts resulting from sequestration will put those efforts in jeopardy, delay the opening of new satellite offices throughout the country and exacerbate the current backlog of patent applications.  If the USPTO is unable to reduce its backlog, it will diminish businesses’ ability to expedite new innovations into the marketplace.  Sequester budget cuts may also hinder the USPTO’s efforts to improve patent quality, which could make it harder to tackle the growing problem of patent trolls.

SIIA is on record voicing its concerns about the effect of sequestration on the USPTO, and is very supportive of H.R. 2582. We urge Congress to immediately consider and pass H.R. 2582.


Keith Kupferschmid is General Counsel and SVP, Intellectual Property Policy & Enforcement at SIIA.

Intellectual Property Roundup

France Eliminates Threat to Cut Off Internet Pirates (Reuters)
The French government has published an official decree to erase the controversial provision in a copyright piracy law that allowed the courts to cut off Internet access of repeat offenders.

Where the Wild Things Are Sequel Pulled From Kickstarter for Infringing Copyright (paidContent)
A sequel to Maurice Sendak’s Where the Wild Things Are was pulled from Kickstarter after publisher HarperCollins issued a takedown notice. The incident suggests that book publishers are being more vigilant about monitoring new platforms for violations.

Intellectual Property Court Opens in Moscow (The Moscow Times)
The Intellectual Property Court, a specialized arbitration court, opened in Moscow after President Vladimir Putin approved the final list of judges. The court will deal with cases regarding patent rights, trademark violations and other intellectual property disputes.

Why Patent Litigation Was On the Upswing In 2012 (Information Today)
A recent study from PricewaterhouseCoopers reports that 2012 was a “banner year in patent litigation,” largely in part due to “patent trolls.”

Microsoft Settles Thousands of Software Piracy Cases (CNET)
Microsoft announced it settled 3,265 software piracy cases worldwide in the past year. Thirty-five of these cases were in the U.S., in 19 different states; and, 3,230 were international cases that took place in 42 different countries.


Keith Kupferschmid is General Counsel and SVP, Intellectual Property Policy & Enforcement at SIIA.

SIIA Says TTIP Negotiators Must Recognize Importance of Digital Trade; Create Trade Agreement as Model for 21st Century

SIIA today called on U.S. and EU negotiators to lower barriers to digital trade as part of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP).

Together America and the EU account for around $30 trillion in annual output, almost half the world total. Of that production, Digital services are a growing, and increasingly essential, part of both the U.S. and EU economies, and they play a huge role in supporting job creation and economic growth worldwide. For these economic benefits to continue, software and information companies must have the ability to easily move data across borders and to locate computer facilities where it is most economically feasible. We urge negotiators to recognize this important high-tech reality and to lower barriers to trade in digital services.

SIIA believes that a primary goal of the ongoing negotiations should be to establish a trade agreement, between the world’s two largest digital services economies, that can serve as a model for 21st Century trade agreements. Preventing restrictions on cross-border data flows and technology localization infrastructure requirements are absolutely critical to the reality of a trade environment that spurs digital trade and allows countries to prepare all of its citizens and enterprises for the global 21st Century economy.

SIIA also wants the TTIP to ensure that digital products, regardless of their classification as a good or service, receive market access, national treatment, most favored nation treatment, and other benefits of open markets. And finally, we urge negotiators to recognize that intellectual property protection is crucial element to enable digital trade in services.


David LeDuc is Senior Director, Public Policy at SIIA. He focuses on e-commerce, privacy, cyber security, cloud computing, open standards, e-government and information policy. Follow the SIIA public policy team on Twitter at @SIIAPolicy.

Intellectual Property Roundup

New Zealand Web Service Allows Users to Block Location (The Wall Street Journal)
Customers of New Zealand telecommunications provider Slingshot can now block their location and gain access to foreign Web services such as Netflix, bringing into question how long copyright holders can continue to bar users in specific regions from accessing their content.

Court Rules No Class-Action Status in Google Book Case (Bloomberg Businessweek)
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals stripped a group representing authors of its class-action status in a lawsuit brought against Google over claims that its plan to create the world’s largest digital library will violate copyrights.

Patent Exam Saves Cities From Suits, Group Says (Courthouse News Service)
The Electronic Frontier Foundation says it has curbed patent holder ArrivalStar from going after cities and transit agencies that use vehicle-tracking systems by having the patent’s legitimacy re-examined.

BitTorrent: We Don’t Deal in Pirated Content (CNET)
In an effort to clear its name association with pirated movies, music and games, BitTorrent’s vice-president of marketing penned a blog post saying that while BitTorrent built the open-source, peer-to-peer technology used for content sharing, it does not endorse piracy in any shape or form.

New York City Secures .NYC Top-Level Domain (PCMag)
New York City announced that ICANN approved its request for the .nyc top-level domain, making the city one of the first in the world to be granted one of these location-specific domains.

ICE, European Partners Seize 328 Internet Domains Selling Counterfeit Goods in Coordinated Operation (U.S. Dept. of Homeland Security)
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) and several law enforcement agencies in Europe, coordinated by the European Police Office (Europol), announced the seizure of 328 domain names in two related operations. The seized domain names were associated with websites illegally selling counterfeit merchandise online to unsuspecting consumers.


Keith Kupferschmid is General Counsel and SVP, Intellectual Property Policy & Enforcement at SIIA.

Congressman Lipinski releases report on Patent Trolls

Patent Assertion Entities (PAE’s), more commonly known as Patent Trolls, have been a problem for the tech community for a number of years.  Recently, they have started to branch out into suing retail companies, government agencies and other end users.  On June 25th Congressman Dan Lipinski (D-Ill) sent a letter to the FTC and released a report titled Trolling for a Public Trough: How Patent Assertion Entities Cost Tax Payers detailing how PAE’s are attacking the U.S. Post Office, city governments, utilities, and transit agencies including Metra in his district.

According to Dan Lipinski’s article, transit agencies are being sued by two notorious off-shore patent trolls — ArrivalStar S.A. and Melvino Technologies — over their use of GPS software that allows them to monitor the location of their trains/buses and to notify commuters when they will be arriving at  specific stops.  These companies have filed over 250 lawsuits against companies and agencies in the transportation industry.  According to Lipinski’s report, because of the millions of dollars it could cost to defend a patent suit, these companies and agencies prefer not to litigate the case in court and instead “opt to quickly settle, agreeing to purchase licenses for fees reportedly ranging from $30,000 to $100,000”.  Patent Trolls have brought suits against transit agencies in California, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Texas, and Washington.

“The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has drastically narrowed the patent owned by ArrivalStar after Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) filed a formal request to reexamine the patent’s legitimacy” was announced on Thursday in a ruling that will help to hopefully curb patent troll abuse in the future.

Ken WaschDenys Emmert is the Public Policy intern at SIIA. He has a degree in marketing and political science from Florida State University.